Whatever side of the debate you fall on regarding Auston Trusty’s red card, there is little argument that the incident dramatically shifted momentum in Celtic’s defeat to Hibernian F.C..
The dismissal came from a Celtic corner — a moment that should have presented an attacking opportunity — making the outcome even more frustrating for the home side. David Gray’s team capitalised, securing their first win at Parkhead since 2010.
Opinion has been split in the aftermath. While Ally McCoist suggested the defender was unfortunate to be sent off, James McFadden took a far firmer stance, branding Trusty’s reaction “utter madness.”
The incident, categorised as violent conduct, occurred after Jamie McGrath grabbed hold of Trusty’s shoulder inside the box. Trusty responded by forcefully striking McGrath’s arm — a reaction McFadden believes crossed the line. Although some felt McGrath exaggerated the contact, McFadden insisted the decisive factor was the level of force used.
Speaking on Sky Sports Football, McFadden explained that regardless of where the contact landed, the aggression behind it justified the red card. In his view, Trusty could have no real complaints given the nature of his actions.
Celtic now face a decision over whether to appeal. The club previously challenged a red card shown to Trusty against Hearts earlier in the season, but that appeal was unsuccessful and resulted in a suspension. This time, however, there may be a stronger case depending on interpretation.
The incident has once again placed VAR decisions in Scotland under scrutiny, with debate continuing over consistency and application.
Whether or not Celtic choose to contest the ruling, the sending-off proved pivotal on the day — and has sparked fresh controversy in an already heated title race.
Leave a Reply