New VAR verdict emerges after Celtic penalty controversy vs Dundee

Celtic have been told it was “incredible” that Tomas Cvancara did not win a penalty during the goalless Scottish Cup tie with Dundee.

The striker was involved in a physical challenge with defender Luke Graham near the edge of the box.

Although the contact continued into the penalty area and Cvancara went down, referee Ryan Lee awarded a free kick just outside the area. VAR official David Dickinson reviewed the incident and supported the on-field decision.

The Scottish FA later clarified the ruling, stating that a foul can only be penalized at the initial point of contact — which officials deemed to be outside the box.

However, former Premier League and FIFA referee Keith Hackett disagreed.

He argued the player was still being pushed while inside the area and said a penalty should have been awarded. Hackett also suggested VAR should have sent the referee to the pitchside monitor for a second look.