Celtic questioned over missed chance to sign Kalvin Phillips on deadline day
Celtic faced a tricky situation as the transfer window closed, with Nottingham Forest making late bids for Arne Engels. The timing left little room to act, and with no replacement lined up, the Parkhead hierarchy opted to reject the offers.
However, some believe there may have been an alternative already available — Manchester City midfielder Kalvin Phillips, a player Pep Guardiola has not been using regularly.
The topic was discussed on Open Goal, where pundits questioned why Celtic did not attempt to bring in the England international, who instead joined Sheffield United on loan.
With Celtic still seeking more steel and defensive balance in midfield, Phillips was viewed by some as an ideal fit. Si Ferry admitted the suggestion might sound ambitious but felt the Scottish champions should at least have explored the possibility.
Ross McCormack echoed that view, pointing out that Celtic and Manchester City have had dealings in recent windows, suggesting communication channels likely existed.
One major obstacle, though, would have been finances. Phillips is understood to be on a high wage at City, and it remains unclear how much of that salary Sheffield United are covering during his loan spell.
Still, the debate highlights ongoing questions around Celtic’s midfield depth and whether a bold move for a player of Phillips’ profile could have addressed those concerns.
While Engels stayed put, the discussion around what might have been continues among supporters and pundits alike.
Leave a Reply