‘Good signing’: Jamie Carragher thinks 28-year-old PL player would be strong signing for Newcastle in January.

Jamie Carragher believes that a 28-year-old Premier League player would be an excellent acquisition for Newcastle in January.Jamie Carragher is of the opinion that Newcastle United would be wise to acquire Kalvin Phillips in January, but he does have one concern.

JEDDAH, SAUDI ARABIA – DECEMBER 22: Kalvin Phillips of Manchester City celebrating after the FIFA Club World Cup Final between Manchester City and Fluminense at King Abdullah Sports City on December 22, 2023 in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. (Photo by Khalid Alhaj/MB Media/Getty Images)

The Magpies’ interest in the 28-year-old appears to have increased, as Manchester City is now prepared to loan the midfielder to Newcastle. They are not going to stand in his way, and Eddie Howe’s side are reportedly confident in their ability to finalize a deal.Obtaining Kalvin Phillips on loan would be an excellent way to begin the month of January, given that the Magpies have struggled in the midfield since Sandro Tonali’s suspension began. The former Leeds player will be eager to impress as he strives to represent England at Euro 2024 and cover the void left by the Italian.

Although the acquisition may appear to be a logical one, Jamie Carragher, a former Liverpool defender, has expressed one concern.

Jamie Carragher poses a thought-provoking inquiry to Kalvin Phillips.

In his most recent column for the Telegraph, Carragher discussed Newcastle and the Magpies’ pursuit of Kalvin Phillips.He wrote that Newcastle are reportedly considering acquiring Kalvin Phillips in January.

“It would be prudent to sign him.”

“However, that does not change the fact that City does not want him, and other top-four clubs in search of defensive midfielders have made the decision not to pursue him.”It is evident that Newcastle recognizes something exceptional in Phillips.

Although I can appreciate Carragher’s position, I do not believe his argument to be particularly significant.

Manchester City has no interest in him. However, Pep Guardiola’s squad already possesses the world’s best defensive midfielder, and they claimed the quadruple last season. One should not be ashamed of not meeting the standards of that particular team.

The fact that Phillips is not being targeted by the top teams in the division is also inconsequential. That does not exactly equate to quality. I’m willing to wager that every member of the Premier League’s elite wishes they had challenged us for Bruno Guimaraes, Alexander Isak, or Sven Botman at this moment.

Clearly, this scenario differs slightly in that Phillips’ predicament is readily apparent to all, but the absence of bids from our competitors should not deter us.

Newcastle must be astute in the transfer market, and their astuteness in talent identification since the ownership transition is praiseworthy. Although Phillips is by no means a mystery, the club clearly sees promise in him and believes he has the ability to contribute significantly at St James’ Park.